Vegan diets may not be best for dogs, after all

The debate over the best diet for our beloved dogs has been raging for years, with raw food enthusiasts, kibble connoisseurs, and now, vegan proponents, all vying for the title of “healthiest” diet. 

A 2022 study made headlines claiming that a vegan diet was the healthiest and least hazardous choice for dogs, but a new analysis from the University of Liverpool challenges those findings. 

Vegan dog diet study

The 2022 study, which garnered significant attention, relied on an online survey of dog owners who were asked about their dogs’ diets, veterinary care, and overall health. The study’s results suggested that dogs fed either a raw meat or vegan diet seemed to be healthier than those fed a conventional diet.

However, it’s important to examine the methodology and potential limitations of any scientific study. The study’s reliance on owner perceptions and its observational design raised questions about the validity of its conclusions.

Owner-reported data can be subjective and may not accurately reflect the actual health of the dogs. Additionally, an observational study design can show correlations but cannot prove cause-and-effect relationships. Therefore, the findings must be interpreted with caution.

Reanalysis of vegan dog diet

Researchers at the University of Liverpool decided to take a closer look at the data from the original study. They reanalyzed the data using different statistical techniques, focusing on one key outcome: owner opinions of dog health.

“On first reading this paper in 2022, it was evident that the study exclusively relied upon owner survey data and had an observational design, meaning that the associations between diet type and dog health could only suggest a possible correlation and not causality,” explained Professor Alex German, an animal medicine expert.

The Liverpool team’s analysis revealed that the dog’s age was the most significant factor influencing owner perceptions of dog health. Other important variables included owner age, owner education, and breed size. These factors strongly impacted how owners viewed their dogs’ health.

Veterinary care variables also played a role but had less influence compared to the dog’s age and the other mentioned factors. The analysis found minimal association between feeding a vegan diet and owner opinions of health. This means that whether a dog was fed a vegan diet or not had little effect on how owners perceived their dogs’ health.

Study implications

“Crucially, we cannot draw a firm conclusion as to what diet type is actually best for dogs; this was never possible given the nature of the original dataset and study design. However, we can conclude that variables other than dog diet are more strongly associated with owner opinions about the health of their dog,” noted Professor Richard Barrett-Jolley, an expert in neuropharmacology.

So, where does this leave dog owners who are considering a vegan diet for their furry friends? It’s important to remember that the new analysis doesn’t definitively prove or disprove the benefits of a vegan diet for dogs. Instead, it highlights the need for more rigorous research to determine the true impact of diet on canine health.

Dog owners should consider that the current evidence does not strongly support the health benefits of vegan diets for dogs. This means more comprehensive studies are necessary to understand how different diets affect dogs. Until then, it’s best for owners to consult with veterinarians and rely on established dietary guidelines to ensure their dogs’ health and well-being.

Role of veterinary guidance

If you’re considering switching your dog to a vegan diet, consult your veterinarian. They can help you assess your dog’s individual needs and ensure that any dietary changes are made safely and gradually. Under veterinary supervision, a well-formulated vegan diet can provide all the necessary nutrients for a dog to thrive.

The debate over the best diet for dogs continues. One thing is clear: more research is needed. Scientists must study the long-term effects of different diets on canine health.

Only with comprehensive research can we understand the true impact of various diets on dogs. The reanalysis of the 2022 study serves as a reminder that scientific findings are not always definitive. 

The study is published in the journal PLoS ONE.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–