Vega star system discovery forces us to rethink planet formation

Where did planets come from? This question has intrigued skywatchers and astronomers for many years.

In the 18th century, Immanuel Kant and Pierre-Simon Laplace proposed that planets were born from a disk of dust and gas surrounding the nascent Sun.

This theory was based on the observation that all planets revolve around the Sun in the same plane and share a common direction of orbit. The scientists compared this particular trait to a record spinning on a phonograph.

Planets around young stars

It was only after two centuries that the theory was backed up with compelling evidence. When IRAS (Infrared Astronomical Satellite) captured the curious excess of infrared light from the dust around the star Vega, it supported the idea of disks forming around young stars.

But as we continue to dig deeper and explore further, we stumble upon new surprises. When astronomers from the University of Arizona decided to aim for a closer look at the Vega system using the Hubble and James Webb Space Telescopes, they discovered something intriguing.

It appears the Vega disk is phenomenally smooth. The characteristic churning and plowing seen in other stellar disks, usually caused by planets, is absent here.

In fact, the Vega disk seems almost as flat as a pancake, showing no evidence of any planets. This challenges our previous understanding and calls for a reassessment of the variety of planetary systems.

“Our observations of Vega surprise us at every turn, and force us to rethink our understanding of exoplanetary systems,” said study lead author Kate Su.

Tale of two stars

Fomalhaut is a star similar to Vega in terms of distance, age, and temperature. Yet, their systems show stark architectural differences. Fomalhaut has three debris belts, indicating the potential presence of planets that could be regulating the dust into rings.

“Given the physical similarity between the stars of Vega and Fomalhaut, why does Fomalhaut seem to have been able to form planets and Vega didn’t?” said George Rieke of the University of Arizona, a member of the research team.

“What’s the difference? Did the circumstellar environment, or the star itself, create that difference? What’s puzzling is that the same physics is at work in both,” added study co-author Schuyler Wolff.

History of Vega star system

Vega was the first star that hinted at the possibility of life-bearing planets – a theory proposed by Immanuel Kant in 1775.

Many decades later, in 1984, NASA’s IRAS detected an excess of warm dust around Vega, interpreted as a shell or disk of dust. Subsequent observations with telescopes confirmed this fact but couldn’t lend any significant details.

“The Hubble and Webb observations together provide so much more detail that they are telling us something completely new about the Vega system that nobody knew before,” said Rieke.

Re-evaluating planet formation

The unexpected discovery of Vega’s serene disk indicates that astronomers should reconsider prevailing theories of planet formation.

Traditionally, the chaotic churning of circumstellar disks, with their evident gaps and structures, has been indicative of planetary forces at work – shepherding dust and gas into ordered arrangements.

Yet, Vega’s lack of these hallmarks suggests alternative mechanisms might govern system development in some stars. Could magnetic fields, stellar winds, or even the initial density and composition of the protoplanetary disk play a more pivotal role than previously imagined?

Further investigations into Vega and similar systems could improve our understanding of the diverse pathways planetary systems might take, challenging conventional wisdom and broadening our cosmic perspective.

Implications for astrobiology

Stars like Vega and Fomalhaut have profound implications for astrobiology, particularly in the quest to identify potentially habitable exoplanets. The presence or absence of planets within these systems influences the potential for life-sustaining environments.

If systems can evolve with little or no planetary formation disturbances, as Vega suggests, we may need to redefine the criteria used to search for habitable worlds.

The serene disk of Vega, devoid of planetary influences, prompts questions about habitability outer limits and whether lifeless planets might yet harbor conditions capable of fostering life in nontraditional habitats.

This new vista in planetary science reshapes not just our celestial maps, but potentially the very parameters of life itself in the universe.

Discoveries beyond stars like Vega

The Hubble Space Telescope has been churning out revolutionary discoveries and enhancing our understanding of the universe for over three decades now.

However, it isn’t the only tool to accomplish this Herculean task. Hubble, managed by the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center and supported by Lockheed Martin Space, continues its exploration, while the James Webb Space Telescope is also making giant strides.

Webb, an international collaboration led by NASA in partnership with the European Space Agency (ESA) and Canadian Space Agency, surveys our solar system, investigates distant worlds, and probes mysterious structures and origins of our universe.

Two papers from the Arizona team will be published in The Astrophysical Journal.

Image Credit: NASA, ESA, STScI, S. Wolff (University of Arizona)

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–