The universe is less 'clumpy' than it should be, but why is that a bad thing?

New research provides fresh insights into the distribution of matter in the cosmos over its 13.8 billion-year history. The study suggests our universe has become “messier and more complicated” over time, with a less “clumpy” distribution of matter than initially expected.

“Our work cross-correlated two types of datasets from complementary, but very distinct, surveys. For the most part, the story of structure formation is remarkably consistent with the predictions from Einstein’s gravity,” noted Matthew Madhavacheril, a cosmologist at the University of Pennsylvania. 

“We did see a hint for a small discrepancy in the amount of expected clumpiness in recent epochs, around four billion years ago, which could be interesting to pursue.”

Cosmic structures and CMB

To explore the evolution of cosmic structures, the research team integrated data from two major astronomical surveys: the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT) and the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI).

“ACT, covering approximately 23% of the sky, paints a picture of the universe’s infancy by using a distant, faint light that’s been travelling since the Big Bang,” explained Joshua Kim, a graduate researcher in Madhavacheril’s group. 

“Formally, this light is called the cosmic microwave background (CMB), but we sometimes just call it the universe’s baby picture because it’s a snapshot of when it was around 380,000 years old.”

Understanding CMB – the basics

Scientists measure this faint cosmic microwave background radiation to understand how our universe began and evolved.

They detect it as a uniform, low-level microwave signal coming from every direction in space. This signal has cooled over billions of years, but it still carries vital clues about the early moments of the cosmos.

Researchers study the CMB to learn about the distribution of matter and energy shortly after the Big Bang.

By analyzing its tiny temperature fluctuations, they can trace the formation of galaxies and large-scale structures in the universe.

Gravitation lensing and CMB

As the ancient light from the CMB travels through the cosmos, it encounters massive structures like galaxy clusters that warp its path through a phenomenon known as gravitational lensing – a concept first predicted by Albert Einstein over a century ago. 

This gravitational lensing effect distorts the CMB, allowing cosmologists to infer properties such as matter distribution and age.

“The LRGs from DESI are like a more recent picture of the universe, showing us how galaxies are distributed at varying distances,” Kim said, comparing the data to the universe’s high school yearbook photo. 

“It’s a powerful way to see how structures have evolved from the CMB map to where galaxies stand today.”

The universe and clumpy matter

By merging the ACT’s lensing maps with DESI’s LRG data, the researchers achieved an unprecedented overlap between ancient and recent cosmic history.

This integration enabled a direct comparison of early- and late-universe measurements.

“This process is like a cosmic CT scan, where we can look through different slices of cosmic history and track how matter clumped together at different epochs. It gives us a direct look into how the gravitational influence of matter changed over billions of years,” Madhavacheril said.

The analysis revealed a small discrepancy: the expected clumpiness or density fluctuations at later epochs did not entirely align with predictions.

The metric Sigma 8 (σ8), which measures the amplitude of matter density fluctuations, indicated less clumping than anticipated.

“Lower values of σ8 indicate less clumping than expected, meaning that cosmic structures might have developed differently than current models suggest,” Kim explained.

Implications and future directions

While the observed discrepancy in σ8 is not statistically strong enough to confirm new physics, it opens the door to intriguing possibilities. 

If the deviation is not due to chance, it could suggest that unaccounted-for physics – such as the role of dark energy – may be influencing cosmic structure formation more than previously understood.

However, according to Kim, this discrepancy isn’t strong enough to suggest new physics conclusively – it’s still possible that this deviation is purely by chance.

Moving forward, the research team plans to utilize more powerful telescopes, like the upcoming Simons Observatory, to refine these measurements with higher precision. 

This will enable a clearer view of cosmic structures and help determine whether the observed discrepancy is a sign of new physical phenomena or a result of statistical variance.

Less clumpy universe, but it’s still evolving

The study conducted by Joshua Kim and Mathew Madhavacheril highlights that the universe’s matter distribution is evolving in a manner that is slightly less clumpy than what Einstein’s gravity-based models predict. 

While the primary narrative of structure formation remains consistent with established theories, the small discrepancies observed around four billion years ago suggest that there may be additional factors influencing the evolution of cosmic structures.

As the scientific community continues to explore these findings, the integration of advanced observational data and sophisticated statistical models will be crucial in unraveling the complexities of the universe’s ongoing evolution.

The study is published in the Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–