Strange signal detected at CERN could be Toponium, but what is that?

The top quark stands out for its large mass among all known fundamental particles. It interacts intensely in the context of particle physics, yet it vanishes almost as quickly as it is created.

A hint of something unexpected has emerged from recent data gathered by the CMS experiment at CERN. Dr. Luca Malgeri, a leading analyst from the CMS collaboration, notes that this sign of a potential new composite state has brought a mix of excitement and caution among researchers.

Unraveling the toponium surprise

The data indicates that top quark-antiquark pairs might temporarily form toponium, a bound state much smaller than the well-known bottomonium. This idea has long floated around as a theoretical possibility but was considered too difficult to confirm.

In contrast to bottomonium and charmonium, both discovered decades ago in the United States, toponium would be unique for decaying in a different way.

A top quark exists for only about the time it takes light to move 0.1 femtometer, so it typically breaks apart before matter and antimatter annihilation can occur.

The top quark puzzle

“A significant excess of events is observed near the kinematic top-antitop threshold,” wrote the CMS Collaboration group.

Observations show that these heavy particles appear more frequently than standard calculations predict at the lowest energy needed to create a top quark–antiquark pair.

This surplus seems to align with a toponium production cross section of 8.8 picobarns, with roughly 15% uncertainty.

Researchers are also open to the idea that another unknown particle, such as an additional Higgs-like boson, might explain the extra events.

Why toponium threshold matters

The fact that the excess appears right at the top-antitop production threshold is a big deal. That’s the lowest energy level at which these heavy particles can form, so any unusual activity there draws attention.

Threshold effects can hint at new physics because that’s where subtle interactions become noticeable. At this boundary, even small shifts in how particles behave can signal new forces or temporary states like toponium.

Quantum chromodynamics describes how quarks join to form hadrons, from protons to more unusual combinations like tetraquarks. When it comes to toponium, the strong force brings together a top quark and its antiparticle if conditions allow.

Earlier examples of quark antiquark pairs include charmonium, noted for linking charm quarks, and bottomonium, discovered at Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory in 1977. Toponium, if confirmed, would close the set of quarkonia formed from heavier quarks.

Size matters at the subatomic scale

The potential size of toponium would be smaller than any previously observed hadron, which are particles made of quarks.

Bottomonium, the current record-holder, measures around 0.4 femtometers, while toponium’s size would likely fall well below that mark.

This matters because studying such a compact structure could provide insights into how the strong force behaves at extremely short distances.

If confirmed, it would give physicists a tighter lens to study interactions between heavy quarks where quantum effects dominate.

Implications for future research

Scientists see this potential bound state as a window into fundamental forces at very high energies. The top quark’s mass is nearly 184 times that of a proton, so toponium holds clues to how mass, short lifetimes, and strong interactions can shape particle behavior.

The synergy of CMS and ATLAS is expected to sharpen results by combining different analysis methods. Both experiments are essential for confirming whether the observed signals are tied to toponium or fit an alternative scenario that requires changes to the Standard Model.

Pushing standard model boundaries

Each fresh insight into top quarks places new demands on the current theory of fundamental particles. This part of the energy frontier also offers a path toward clarifying how concepts like dark matter might be linked to known interactions.

Physicists intend to refine their measurements of heavy particle states as the LHC ramps up for future runs. They remain determined to see if toponium truly exists or if another explanation lurks behind the extra top quark-antiquark production.

If toponium becomes a confirmed part of the particle zoo, it could help complete the story of how matter organizes itself at the smallest scales.

Scientists have long sought a deeper understanding of how short-lived particles behave in high-energy environments.

This discovery wouldn’t just fill a missing slot in the known list of quark–antiquark states. It would also sharpen tools for testing new physics theories that go beyond the Standard Model, which still leaves major questions unanswered.

The study is published in Reports on Progress in Physics.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–