Media and stereotypes influence how we judge different accents

Accents spark ongoing debates nationwide. Some insist they can instantly identify a person’s origins from the accent, while others dismiss speech differences as insignificant.

Kathryn Campbell-Kibler, associate professor of linguistics at The Ohio State University, led a study that investigates this clash. She and her colleagues explored why individuals rate entire regions as highly accented but rarely detect any special traits in real voices from those same areas.

Questioning what’s “normal”

People in the United States have long equated certain speech patterns with unusual regional traits. In everyday conversation, though, many seem to ignore those so-called markers of accent in actual speakers.

“People probably don’t learn who has an accent from hearing someone talk and thinking, ‘huh, they sound funny’ – even though sometimes it feels like that’s how we do it,” said Campbell-Kibler.

She based her observation on what participants revealed during interviews and recorded evaluations of different voices, noting that the story they tell about how accents work doesn’t match their reactions in person.

Vowels and the perception of accents

Researchers have long emphasized how Americans rely on specific vowel sounds to sense whether a person speaks with an accent.

Vowels can shift in subtle ways depending on region, social background, or even personal habit. Scholarly work shows that people’s speech perception is influenced by context, environment, and individual attitudes.

One example that has drawn attention is the pin/pen merger, in which words like “pen” sound like “pin.” This phenomenon appears in several southern states and adjacent regions, prompting many to label such areas as “obviously accented.”

Looking for a disconnect

Campbell-Kibler’s team recruited a broad mix of individuals in Columbus, Ohio. Participants assessed various recorded voices and then gave their anecdotal thoughts on which parts of the state “definitely” had residents with an accent.

A puzzling pattern emerged. While people gave high accent ratings to voices from certain places, they rarely flagged actual speech recordings from those same locations as particularly accented. 

“It is perplexing. We don’t know the full answer for why this is,” said Campbell-Kibler. She noted that understanding how people form accent perceptions will require further research into cognitive and social influences.

Cultural cues and stereotypes

This apparent contradiction might spring from what we absorb from friends, family, and pop culture. Many who think an area sounds “different” do so thanks to shared anecdotes or media portrayals, rather than due to direct observation of vowel shifts or altered consonants.

It is possible that common expressions like “you sound so country” plant ideas in our heads before we ever talk to someone from that region. By the time we actually meet a person from that location, we might subconsciously downplay any distinctive twang.

Ohio’s unique geography and population flows often make it feel like a microcosm of American speech variants.

Different parts of the state are casually labeled Midland, Northern, or Southern in linguistic surveys. Yet many Ohioans still champion the idea that their region is accent-neutral. This mental map of “who has an accent” doesn’t always align with reality.

Why we don’t notice some accents

Findings like these hint that accent awareness might develop on multiple levels. One factor may be cultural messaging that lumps entire places together as odd or exotic.

Another aspect is the genuine variation in vowel sounds, intonation, and word choice that sets regions apart, which people may not notice in casual encounters.

Some linguists suspect that social identification – whom we see as “like us” or “not like us” – shapes why certain sounds register as heavily accented.

Others propose that mass media tropes, from exaggerated comedic roles to dramatic movie characters, form the root of widespread stereotypes.

How accent bias affects daily life

Accent perceptions can lead to misunderstandings and social barriers. They affect hiring decisions, education, and friendships.

Recognizing that we might judge speech based on preconceived notions, rather than actual patterns, could help us become more mindful listeners.

Small, everyday interactions might shift our views. Learning that someone from a supposedly “very accented” region actually speaks in ways we barely acknowledge as different is a step toward appreciating the variety that surrounds us.

Campbell-Kibler’s research sparks ongoing discussions about speech, identity, and how cultural beliefs shape what we hearing. Examining why our ears play tricks on us may encourage more open-minded exchanges.

Language is personal, but it also unites us. Understanding how we label one another’s way of speaking could bring a greater sense of fairness to how we communicate across regions.

The study is published in the Journal of Sociolinguistics.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–