Judging your happiness makes you less happy

Happiness is an omnipresent quest, an ever-elusive goal that many strive to achieve throughout life. But what if we are judging our happiness too much?

The pursuit of happiness is often seen as the holy grail of a meaningful life, yet this quest could potentially be a double-edged sword, leading to unintended consequences.

New research published by the American Psychological Association suggests that constantly measuring and evaluating your own happiness could cause it to wither away, negatively impacting overall life satisfaction and psychological well-being.

Hidden costs of judging personal happiness

For their investigation, the researchers conducted three experiments involving more than 1,800 participants.

The results of the analysis showed that having concerns or judgments about one’s level of happiness was associated with lower well-being, partly due to increased negativity and disappointment about positive events.

Lead researcher Felicia Zerwas, PhD, was a doctoral student at the University of California-Berkeley during this research and is now a postdoctoral researcher at New York University.

Zerwas explained that thinking too much about one’s own happiness might relate to fears of not measuring up or not being as happy as others.

“There are plenty of societal pressures, at least within the United States, which encourage the fallacy that people must feel happy all of the time to achieve greater well-being,” she noted.

The social constraint of constant joy

In many societies, as Zerwas noted, there is an overwhelming amount of pressure to maintain constant happiness as a key to life satisfaction. However, the study’s findings suggest otherwise.

Zerwas emphasized that allowing yourself to experience and accept your emotions, whether they are positive or negative, could be a useful tool in the pursuit of happiness and well-being.

Contrary to some previous studies, the current research found that simply viewing happiness as an essential goal did not negatively affect well-being. Instead, the issue emerged in the judgment of one’s own happiness.

Focus of the research

The study included diverse samples of participants, such as students from Yale University, community members from Denver and Berkeley, California, and online participants from across the United States and Canada.

The participants were asked detailed questions about their beliefs regarding happiness and their overall psychological well-being.

Those who were particularly concerned about their own level of happiness demonstrated significantly lower overall life satisfaction, poorer psychological well-being, and greater depressive symptoms.

Moreover, these individuals exhibited more negativity towards positive experiences, highlighting the detrimental effects of excessive self-judgment and high expectations on personal joy.

The double-edged sword of judging happiness

In light of these findings, cultivating authenticity in our emotional experiences is crucial.

The pressure to project constant happiness can disconnect us from our true feelings and distort self-perception. Instead of striving for an idealized version of happiness, we should embrace our authentic selves, acknowledging both the highs and lows of our emotions.

Practicing authenticity fosters a deeper understanding of our emotions and builds resilience. Experiencing a full spectrum of emotions, including discomfort and sadness, as natural parts of life can enhance overall well-being by allowing genuine responses without self-judgment.

Cultivating a supportive social environment is also essential. Surrounding ourselves with individuals who value emotional honesty can help mitigate societal pressures. Open conversations about mental health and emotional struggles normalize varying emotional states, reminding us we are not alone.

Ultimately, the pursuit of happiness should be a fluid journey guided by self-acceptance and understanding. Embracing authenticity and fostering a supportive community allows us to navigate our emotional lives with grace, finding fulfillment in the richness of our shared human experience.

Mindfulness as a path to well-being

In addition to embracing authenticity, integrating mindfulness practices into our daily lives can further enhance our emotional well-being and life satisfaction.

Mindfulness encourages us to be present in the moment, allowing us to experience our emotions without judgment. This practice can help us manage stress, improve focus, and find a sense of inner peace.

By combining mindfulness with authenticity, we can develop a more holistic approach to our emotional health, leading to a more balanced and fulfilling life.

The study is published in the journal Emotion.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–