How the brain uses context to make complex decisions
Life often presents us with complex situations requiring decisions influenced by multiple factors. Our ability to adapt and make sense of these ambiguous scenarios is largely dependent on specific brain regions: the orbitofrontal cortex (OFC) and the dorsal hippocampus (DH).
Researchers at University of California Santa Barbara (UCSB) have delved into the workings of these regions, revealing their collaborative roles in resolving ambiguity and enabling rapid learning.
Context-dependent decision-making
The findings, published in the journal Current Biology, provide new insights into how these brain areas help us navigate context-dependent scenarios and adapt our behavior accordingly.
“I would argue that that’s the foundation of cognition,” said senior author Ron Keiflin, a neuroscientist at UCSB. “That’s what makes us not behave like simple robots, always responding in the same manner to every stimulus.
“Our ability to understand that the meaning of certain stimuli is context-dependent is what gives us flexibility; it is what allows us to act in a situation-appropriate manner.”
The context that informs decisions
Consider the act of deciding whether to answer a ringing phone. Your response depends on factors such as where you are, who might be calling, and the time of day.
These elements form the “context,” which informs your decision. According to Keiflin, this cognitive flexibility stems from the interplay between the OFC and DH.
The OFC, located just above the eyes, is associated with decision-making, reward valuation, and planning, while the DH, deeper in the brain, is crucial for spatial navigation and memory.
Both regions contribute to what Keiflin describes as a “cognitive map” – a mental representation of the causal structure of the environment. This map enables the brain to simulate outcomes, predict consequences, and guide actions.
Despite their importance, the specific roles of these regions in contextual disambiguation – determining how stimuli change meaning depending on the context – had not been explicitly tested until now.
Auditory cues in different contexts
To investigate, the researchers designed an experiment involving rats exposed to auditory cues in two different contexts: a brightly lit room and a dark room. Each sound had a context-dependent meaning.
For example, one sound signaled a reward (sugar water) only in the light, while another signaled a reward only in the dark.
Over time, the rats learned to associate each sound with the correct context, demonstrating their understanding by licking the reward cup in anticipation of a treat in one setting but not the other.
The researchers then used chemogenetics to temporarily disable the OFC or DH during the task. When the OFC was deactivated, the rats were no longer able to use the context to predict rewards and regulate their behavior.
However, disabling the DH had little impact on performance, a surprising result given its known role in memory and spatial processing.
Learning enhanced by prior knowledge
While the DH seemed dispensable for recalling learned context-dependent relationships, it proved crucial for learning new ones.
“If I walked into an advanced math lecture, I would understand – and learn – very little. But someone more mathematically knowledgeable would be able to understand the material, which would greatly facilitate learning,” Keiflin explained.
Similarly, once the rats had developed a “cognitive map” of context-dependent relationships, they were able to learn new ones much faster. Training time dropped from over four months to just a few days.
Brain regions working together
Using the same chemogenetic approach, the researchers found that disabling either the OFC or DH impaired the rats’ ability to apply prior knowledge to learn new relationships.
The OFC was essential for applying contextual knowledge to regulate immediate behavior, while the DH enabled the rapid acquisition of new context-dependent relationships.
This dual role highlights the complementary functions of these brain regions in supporting both decision-making and learning.
Implications for neuroscience and education
According to Keiflin, the fact that prior knowledge influences learning is well known in psychology and education, but is often ignored in neuroscience research.
Understanding how the brain uses prior knowledge to facilitate learning could inform educational strategies and interventions for individuals with learning difficulties.
The study also sheds light on the distinct roles of the OFC and DH. While the OFC helps regulate behavior based on contextual knowledge, the DH is more critical for using past experiences to learn new relationships.
Together, these regions enable the brain to adapt to complex, ever-changing environments.
Brain’s ability to use context for decisions
The research highlights the importance of contextual understanding in navigating daily life. Whether it’s deciding to answer a ringing phone or adapting to new information, the brain’s ability to resolve ambiguity is foundational to human cognition.
By unraveling the roles of the OFC and DH, this study not only advances our understanding of brain function but also underscores the intricate mechanisms that enable learning and decision-making.
This knowledge opens avenues for exploring how disruptions in these processes may contribute to conditions such as anxiety or decision-making impairments.
As Keiflin concluded, “a better neurobiological understanding of this rapid learning and inference of context-dependent relations is critical, as this form of learning is probably much more representative of the human learning experience.”
The findings set the stage for future research on how these brain regions interact in complex, real-world scenarios, paving the way for potential applications in education and mental health.
—–
Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.
Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.
—–
