Earworms: The surprising accuracy of our musical memory

Earworms – those persistent tunes that play in our heads unbidden – can be more than a minor annoyance.

Imagine going about your day when, without warning, a song loops repeatedly in your mind.

While these spontaneous musical memories can feel intrusive, earworms offer a fascinating glimpse into the precision of our musical recall.

Unveiling the mystery of earworms

A recent study has shed light on the surprising accuracy of earworms.

Published in the journal Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics, the study revealed that nearly half of participants’ renditions of earworms matched the original pitch of the songs.

This finding challenges prior beliefs about the limitations of musical memory, suggesting that our brains may preserve detailed “absolute pitch” memories even without formal pitch recognition skills.

Earworms, experienced by over 90% of people, are involuntary musical memories that spontaneously play in our minds.

This study indicates that our recall of melodies may be more precise than previously thought, even without external references.

Encountering music in a new light

Matthew G. Evans, PhD candidate at UC Santa Cruz, said he first learned about the field of music cognition from Daniel Levitin’s book This Is Your Brain On Music.

“In that book, he describes a study where they found evidence for absolute pitch recall in voluntarily-recalled musical imagery – and I tried it myself, and it worked, and I’ve been hooked on the topic of musical memory ever since.”

Evans set out to investigate whether this accurate recall extended to spontaneous earworms or was limited only to songs that people purposefully tried to remember.

Earworms: More than just random tunes

The study involved 30 undergraduate students who participated in a two-week research period aimed at exploring the accuracy of spontaneous musical recall.

Using the experience sampling method, the researchers documented these involuntary musical memories in real time by sending participants random text prompts throughout the day.

Students were asked to record any song playing in their minds, capturing the natural occurrence of earworms outside of a controlled laboratory setting.

While most participants had some familiarity with music, none reported having perfect pitch or formal training that would give them an advantage in recalling exact musical notes.

Each recording was analyzed against the original song to determine how closely the pitch matched the song’s actual key.

The findings were striking: 44.7% of the earworms matched the original song’s pitch exactly. When the range was expanded to include recordings within one semitone of the original pitch, nearly 69% of the renditions met this criterion – far surpassing what could be attributed to random chance.

The melodic imprint of our brains

The study also found that pitch accuracy was not significantly affected by recent exposure to a song.

Some participants noted that their earworm was triggered by recently hearing the song, but their ability to match the original pitch remained similar to those whose earworms were not influenced by recent listening.

“When we divided our data into responses where participants said they had recently heard the song and those where they hadn’t, we saw absolutely no difference in absolute pitch accuracy,” noted Evans.

Future research directions

While this study provides valuable insights into how we recall music, it also highlights the need for further research to validate and expand upon these findings.

To gain a broader understanding of how earworms and pitch recall function across different populations, future studies should incorporate a larger and more diverse participant pool, including individuals with no musical background and participants from varied age groups and cultural settings.

By expanding the scope of the research, scientists could explore questions such as whether musical memory accuracy varies by age, cultural exposure to music, or training.

It may also be valuable to investigate whether factors such as musical genres or personal attachment to specific songs influence pitch accuracy in earworms.

This research marks an early step in unraveling the complex mechanisms of our brain’s musical memory.

As future studies build on this foundational work, we may discover more about the intricate ways in which our minds store and retrieve musical information, shedding light on the intersection of memory, perception, and cognitive processes.

The study is published in the journal Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates. 

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–