Children’s screen time shapes their mental health as teens

A new long-term study indicates that children who spend more time on screens during their early years – particularly on phones and tablets – experience higher levels of stress and depressive symptoms once they enter adolescence. 

The eight-year study offers fresh insights for parents deciding when and how to give their kids digital access, especially given the rising mental health challenges among the youth.

According to the experts, between one-quarter and one-third of adolescents worldwide experience mental health issues, with first symptoms usually appearing during the teenage years. 

The researchers see their findings as additional evidence that parents might want to limit screen time and encourage active play, since cultivating certain habits early may serve as a buffer against future psychological distress.

Screens and teen health

Scientists drew data from the Physical Activity and Nutrition in Children (PANIC) study, a project that tracked 187 Finnish children aged between 6 and 9 years until they were 15 to16.

Over the course of eight years, the team monitored the participants’ physical activity, screen time, sleep patterns, and eating behaviors. 

Then, as teenagers, those same participants were assessed for mental health using standardized measures of stress and depressive symptoms.

The findings revealed that teens who accumulated more total screen time, specifically on mobile devices, ended up showing significantly higher levels of stress and depression. 

The role of physical activity

Encouragingly, a high level of physical activity during childhood proved to have the opposite effect.

Teens who remained active – particularly in structured or supervised settings – demonstrated stronger mental health outcomes, even after accounting for factors like body composition, puberty stage, and parents’ educational background. 

This trend was more pronounced among boys, who seemed to derive a greater protective effect against stress from exercise than girls.

Meanwhile, diet quality and sleep duration did not show notable links to teen mental health in this research. 

While this does not rule out their importance for overall well-being, it suggests that daily movement and minimized screen time may have more pronounced effects when it comes to adolescent stress and depression levels.

Early interventions for screen habits

For those wary of introducing personal devices too early, the study’s conclusion is clear: childhood screen behavior can echo into the teenage years, shaping emotional health.

Researchers especially emphasize caution with mobile device use. 

Balanced approaches appear to matter most. Kids who paired more screen time with lower physical activity ended up with the worst mental health outcomes. 

This highlights that focusing on just one of these factors – reducing screen time or encouraging regular exercise – may be less effective than addressing both simultaneously.

The authors also point out that supervised physical activities, such as team sports, can have particularly strong benefits.

This could fuel arguments for policies that increase children’s access to organized athletics, either through schools or community programs. 

The study further indicates that mental health professionals should consider making routine inquiries about technology habits as part of early interventions.

A shifting technological landscape

While the study results are not strictly causal, they highlight the power of everyday choices in shaping long-term psychological outcomes.

Given how quickly technology evolves, the authors warn that this knowledge becomes more and more urgent. 

Social media platforms and mobile games continue to expand, and children are exposed to smartphones at younger ages, making it crucial to recognize how these patterns might affect their mental well-being.

Notably, the study concluded before the recent explosion in newer social media apps, so the current generation may see even more negative consequences of their digital consumption. 

That said, the fundamental takeaway – that more screens plus less physical activity predicts a rougher mental health path – likely remains valid.

Research limitations and future directions

While the study’s eight-year timeframe offers valuable longitudinal data, the final sample of 187 adolescents is small. Many participants dropped out midway, so the final group may not be entirely representative. 

Also, while the researchers tracked overall screen time, they did not distinguish between different types of screen exposure or social media content. Future studies might look at which specific apps or games pose the highest risks.

The research also measured sleep duration but not sleep quality, leaving open questions about how nighttime device use might undermine rest and, in turn, mental health. 

Most notably, the authors highlight that the data cannot prove that one factor directly causes the other. It’s possible, for instance, that children already prone to stress or depression might gravitate more toward screen usage.

Still, as mental health difficulties among younger demographics continue to rise, these findings can guide parents and care providers.

Ensuring kids stay active may mitigate some of those effects, but the broader message is that habits formed early can shape teens’ emotional landscapes in the years to come.

In essence, the authors advise parents to craft balanced digital environments, offering moderate device access and ample opportunities for physical activity and social engagement. 

Full details of the study were published in the JAMA Network Open.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–